Dikke bacteriën geven waarde aan natte drab
A Dutch debate about over-supervision and a large international survey telling the same story: the supervisor relationship shapes a PhD student’s mental health more than almost anything else. In her column, Isabelle Kohler looks at why that relationship so often goes unexamined – and offers four practical steps for PhD students who are already in a difficult one.

Over the past fifteen years, I have supervised countless students – bachelor, master, and PhD. I started with zero skills in this domain and have grown enormously since. My style: human connection, trust, and a lot of independence for the people I work with. But I am also slow with feedback, I struggle to keep up with the latest literature, and troubleshooting sessions drain me. I say this not to confess, but because supervision is hard, and most people doing it never received a single hour of training for it – or followed only a few courses.
Then two things caught my attention – and they pointed in the same direction.
The first was a conversation started by the ‘Jonge Akademi’ (Young Academy) about “Profkippen” – a portmanteau of “plofkip” (broiler chicken) and “professor.” It describes academics, often full professors, who supervise so many PhD students that quality inevitably drops [1]. The Young Academy proposes a limes promovendi: a cap on the number of PhD candidates one person can supervise at the same time. The problem is structural. A small group of academics attracts more and more funding under the current Dutch system, and more funding means more PhD students – whether or not the supervision quality can scale with it.
The second was a preprint published on bioRxiv, based on a survey of 2,600+ early-career researchers across 65 countries (including The Netherlands) and 13 research fields [2]. The numbers are striking: 76% reported that their supervisor had a moderate or significant impact on their mental health. The most common causes of poor wellbeing were disrespectful or dismissive communication, little or no feedback, disregard for personal circumstances, micromanagement, and fostering competition within the team. What PhD students and postdocs valued most in a good supervisor: being supportive rather than boss-like, regular meetings, open communication, clear project management, respect for personal time, and realistic goals.
What can you do if you recognize yourself in that 76%?
The ‘Profkip’ debate and the bioRxiv survey are pointing at the same thing. Supervision is not a side task – the relationship matters more than most PhD students are told when they start, and more than most supervisors were trained for when they took the role.
References:
[1] De Jonge Akademie, ‘Profkip’: a conversation about PhD supervision, https://www.dejongeakademie.nl/en/news/3224666.aspx (accessed 29-05-2026)
[2] X.S. Martinez-Goni, A.J. Marin-Pena, M. Corrochano-Monsalve, A. Bozal-Leorri, bioRxiv, 2026, doi: https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.05.05.722947
—
If you are interested in learning more about how to navigate academia and own your professional choices, do not hesitate to join the NextMinds Community! For this, you have plenty of choices: visit NextMinds website to learn more about my work, sign up for the newsletter, and follow me and NextMinds on LinkedIn.
Elke woensdag in je inbox: het laatste chemie- en life sciences nieuws uit Nederland en Vlaanderen, aangevuld met analyses, achtergronden en meer!
Registreer je gratis en ontvang de nieuwsbrief, creëer je eigen profiel en reageer op onze artikelen.
Register for free and receive our newsletter.
Nog geen opmerkingen
Alleen geregistreerde gebruikers kunnen opmerkingen bij dit artikel plaatsen.
Aanmelden of registreer om te reageren.